By Dako
I started chasing financial independence at the end of 2017. Almost nine years later, nearly everything on this blog has been about how.
How much goes into which account. Which of those accounts would survive a move to Japan. What happens to a green card, a 401(k), an inheritance, or a college fund if we end up living somewhere else. If you’ve been reading this blog, you’ve seen us work through most of those.
This post is the other question. Not how much, and not where. Why.
Part of it is “away from,” and I’d rather say so
I’ll start with the less flattering half. Some of what I want is to get away from something. I’m a little tired of work, and there are parts of it I’m not thrilled with. I won’t get more specific than that on a public blog, and I don’t think the details matter here.
There’s also the arrangement at home. We live on Jay’s salary and invest all of mine. I wrote about that system in a post last week, including the parts that don’t feel great. Jay’s career gets priority and mine bends around it. I carry most of the money decisions on my own. Some days I wonder whether we’re giving up a richer life now for a plan that’s still years out.
So “away from” isn’t zero for me. I just don’t think it can be the whole answer.
Back in 2017, Physician on FIRE called “retire to something” “great advice.” Some of the cautionary stories are hard to forget. The Two Sides of FI podcast ran an episode called “Retired Early and I Hated It,” about the lack of purpose that showed up once the work stopped. Sam Dogen of Financial Samurai, an early retiree himself, told Fortune in 2023 that many early retirees, himself included, are “completely bored out of our minds,” and that early retirement “can also be lonely.”
Those are individual accounts, not a rule. But “I’ll figure it out once I’m free” is a plan I’d never accept for a 401(k). I’m not sure why I was willing to accept it for everything else.
What I actually want the time for (yes, dead languages)
Here’s my list, unedited.
I want to study things that will never pay me a cent. Astronomy. Philosophy. Archaeology. Latin.
A while back, I tried to put it into words. It came out like this: it may not mean anything in real life, but it looks interesting, and I want the time to try. Learn Latin. Study Sumerian and read the oldest books in the world.
I haven’t started any of it. No textbook, no first lesson.
The Sumerian part comes with a small twist. The Epic of Gilgamesh usually gets called the oldest book, but its standard version is written in Akkadian, and the Sumerian Gilgamesh stories survive as separate episodes. Among the oldest surviving works of literature are the Kesh Temple Hymn and the Instructions of Shuruppak, with copies dated to roughly 2600 to 2500 BCE.
Then there’s Enheduanna. She was a daughter of Sargon of Akkad and a high priestess of the moon god at Ur in the 23rd century BCE. She’s often called the earliest author known by name. Some scholars question how much of the work credited to her she wrote herself. I still love that the first name we can attach to human literature may belong to a woman with a very serious day job.
None of this needs a university. Oxford’s Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature puts close to 400 compositions online, each with a transliteration and an English translation. For Latin, there’s the classic Wheelock’s textbook, and there’s Ørberg’s Lingua Latina per se Illustrata, written entirely in Latin. The materials exist. What’s missing is unhurried hours.
Three more items made the list, and they’re less charming but just as real. I want enough slack to give something back to society without first checking whether I can afford the time. I don’t want to be chased by the clock anymore. And I want to do all of this while I still have the physical energy for it.
Why “why” turned into a “where” question, then a “when” question
Our biggest open question, ever since the first post on this site, has been where. A full move to Japan, or two bases. We’ve tried to prepare so that every door stays open. Our decision framework sorts each issue into clocks you can’t stop, one-way doors, and dials you can turn.
Writing down the why didn’t answer the where. It did shrink it a little, at least for my half of the list.
A Sumerian hymn reads the same on either side of the Pacific. The text corpus works on any Wi-Fi connection. Latin doesn’t care which country my mail goes to. Most of what I want is portable, which is a strange thing to discover after so many posts about portable accounts.
Giving back is the exception. What that looks like probably depends on where we live, and I don’t know yet.
The item that grew was the last one, the one about energy. In the framework’s terms, that’s a clock, not a dial.
That reframed the money for me. Our FIRE number has a dollar version and a yen version we still haven’t worked out. Both are dials. We can move them. Nobody gets to move the other one.
There’s research that points the same way, with the usual caution attached. A 2019 study in JAMA Network Open followed 6,985 US adults over 50. People with the lowest sense of purpose had about 2.4 times the risk of dying during the follow-up period, compared with those with the highest. It’s observational, so it can’t show that purpose causes anything. I’m not citing it to scare anyone. I mention it because it suggests the why isn’t a soft extra sitting on top of the spreadsheet.
A few questions for anyone chasing a number without a reason
If you’ve been running the how for years, these might be worth five minutes with a notebook.
- If the money landed tomorrow, what would you do with your first free Tuesday?
- Which parts of your answer are “away from,” and which are “toward”? Both count.
- Would your why survive a move abroad?
- Which items depend on having the energy you have now?
- Is there a small version you could start before the number is reached?
My honest answer to that last one is “not yet.”
Your why doesn’t have to be grand. An hour with a library book counts. So does “I don’t want my calendar running my life,” which is on my own list.
Here’s where I’ve landed for now. Dead languages, the night sky, old questions about how to live, some room to give back, and days that aren’t chasing me. It doesn’t change our number this week. It does make the trade I described last week feel less abstract. I’m investing my whole paycheck so that I can eventually spend my time on things nobody will ever pay me for. Said that way, I still think it’s the right trade, for us, for now.
FAQ
Is it a bad sign if my main reason for FIRE is that I’m tired of work?
Not necessarily. Part of mine is that too. The stories above suggest that “away from” on its own can leave a gap once the job is gone. It may help to add at least one “toward” before you get there.
Do I need a why before I set a FIRE number?
No. But the why decides what the money is for, and that can change where you spend it, and how soon you want to stop.
This article describes one household’s thinking about early retirement and is not financial, tax, or legal advice. Your situation is different from ours. Please talk to a qualified professional before making changes, and see our Disclaimer for details.