Full Move or Two Bases? The Decision Framework We’re Using (and Haven’t Finished)

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Nothing here is personalized advice: see our Disclaimer.

By Dako & Jay

Three months ago, in our first post, we wrote down five things to research before deciding where we’d live after FIRE. The covered expatriate tests. Which US accounts survive a move. Japan’s ten-year inheritance rule. PFICs. And 529 versus NISA for kids whose future country is unknown.

All five are posts now. So are plenty we didn’t plan, from the tax treaty to the spouse visa.

We still haven’t decided. What changed is that we finally understand what kind of decision this is. So here’s the framework we pulled out of those three months, a worksheet you can copy, and our own copy with the blanks left blank.

Three months of research, one pattern

We went in expecting a price comparison. Tax here versus tax there. What we mostly found was time.

Nearly every rule we read had a clock inside it. Some are running today, move or no move. Others start the day one of us takes up residence in Japan. A few choices are doors that only swing one way, where walking through removes options instead of adding them. Price still matters. Order matters more, and the clocks set most of that order.

So the framework sorts every question into one of three kinds:

  • Clock: a counter that runs on its own. You can’t stop it. You can only know where it is.
  • One-way door: a choice that’s hard or impossible to undo.
  • Dial: something you can adjust later, as the picture changes.

The second finding was less comfortable. On paper, “two bases” isn’t a midpoint between moving and staying. Japan doesn’t decide residency by counting to 183 days. It looks at where your life is centered: your home, your family, your work. A family splitting the year will usually be treated as living in one country. If that country is Japan, the ten-year inheritance tail follows the Japanese spouse out the door when they leave.

Two bases can still be a real life, just not a separate tax status. Our framework treats it as either “a full move with long trips” or “staying put with long trips,” depending on where the center lands.

The money axis: clocks that are already running

Dako here, since most of the money reading was mine.

The loudest clock was on my green card. The 8-of-15 test counts every calendar year in which you held the card for even one day. Year eight is behind me. So if I ever hand the card back, the covered expatriate tests apply on that date. There are three: net worth of $2,000,000, average annual income tax above $211,000 for 2026, and five years of certified compliance. Trip any one of them and the exit tax treats me as having sold everything the day before I left.

That clock has turned into a one-way door. Keeping the card means paying for it every year in worldwide tax and reporting. Surrendering it runs the tests. Naturalizing is where I lean, without having decided. It makes the 8-of-15 count irrelevant, because citizens don’t have one, and it means any future renunciation would go straight to the 877A tests. There’s no version where the card sits in a drawer and time fixes it.

Other clocks start only if we move. As a Japanese national, I’d be taxed on worldwide income from the day Japan counts me as living there. The softer non-permanent resident years are for foreign nationals like Jay, not for me. Japan’s own exit tax begins counting that same day for both of us. It can apply to someone leaving with ¥100 million or more in securities after more than five of the previous ten years in Japan. The pension clock runs the other direction. Anyone living in Japan between 20 and 59 has to join the national pension, whatever their nationality, and I have zero Japanese years today. So our move year will decide my Japanese pension years more than any form I could file.

One clock we’re already inside. My parents live in Japan. When the person who passes away lived in Japan, Japanese inheritance tax can reach what an heir receives, wherever that heir lives and wherever the assets sit. For us that question arrives whether we move or not.

The dials are gentler. Most US accounts survive a move. A brokerage may stop mutual fund purchases, a 401(k) stops taking contributions, and the HSA travels worst of all. None of that forces a decision today.

Money moving between the two of us is different, because direction and timing both count. A gift from me to Jay, non-citizen to citizen, has no annual cap. The reverse only gets an annual exclusion, $194,000 for 2026. And gifts made before an exit behave differently from gifts made after one. If we ever need it, the sequence is gift, then exit, then move. We haven’t moved anything between us for this reason. It’s on the list.

And our FIRE number is still only in dollars. That dial we haven’t touched.

The family axis: one base has to be the main one

Jay here. The family questions don’t come with thresholds. I think that’s why they’re harder.

The clearest finding from our post on kids and two countries was about structure, not feelings. Japanese schools start in April and place children by age. A short trial enrollment is up to the local board of education, not something the country guarantees. School systems aren’t built to be cut in half. A two-base family picks a main school and treats the other country as a visit, whatever the calendar says about months.

Language is a clock with no alarm on it. Our kids go to an English-speaking daycare. Dako speaks Japanese to them, but the moment the whole family is in one room, we talk in English. They know the everyday words, bath time and tidy up, oishii and tanoshii. The Japanese picture books get read in Japanese. It’s real, and it’s thin, and nobody sends a reminder about it.

Kids’ savings turned out to be one of the few places where staying undecided is cheap. A 529 stays alive if we move. NISA is for Japan residents only, and for a parent who’s a US person it walks straight into PFIC trouble. Japan’s new NISA for children starts in January 2027, but it’s a tool for after a move, not before one. We fund the 529 and have no NISA. That’s the closest our worksheet gets to “done.”

Estate papers sit here too. We have a trust, wills, and powers of attorney, and we assume all of it gets rewritten once a move becomes concrete.

The life axis has the fewest answers

Still Jay. This is where the research helps least, and where I’m most exposed.

I don’t read Japanese. Anything administrative in Japan goes through Dako. In a full move, that would be the permanent arrangement unless I change it. I’ve taken a 101 class, worked through a textbook on my own, and I watch Japanese YouTube, dramas, and anime. Stop and start. Not a system.

The paperwork side looks more workable. A spouse visa usually runs through a Certificate of Eligibility that takes one to three months, and the visa that comes after it has no work restriction. That’s something we could plan backward from. So far I’ve only researched it.

What nobody can plan backward from is the question our first post asked: which country do we each picture at 75? We haven’t answered it. The worksheet has a row for it anyway, because leaving it off would make the grid look more finished than it is.

The worksheet (copy it)

This table is the whole worksheet. Copy it into a spreadsheet or onto paper. Fill it once per spouse, since several rows have a different answer for each of you. Then add three columns: full move, two bases, stay. Watch which rows change across them. The last column is ours.

#QuestionKindWhere we are
1How many calendar years has each non-citizen held a green card?ClockDako: past year eight
2Keep the card, surrender it, or naturalize?One-way doorLeaning toward naturalizing. Undecided
3On a likely exit date, where would you sit on the three covered expatriate tests?Dial (the date moves it)Our numbers stay off this blog
4Do any gifts between spouses need to happen before an exit or a move? In which direction?One-way door (order matters)Not done. Still considering
5Which accounts travel well, travel with paperwork, or travel badly?DialSorted into three boxes
6Any Japanese funds, NISA, or other PFIC exposure?DialNo NISA. A sliver of Japanese stocks we can’t trade
7Does either of you have parents living in Japan?Clock (already running)Yes, Dako’s
8Which Japanese clocks start on arrival, and for which spouse?ClockDako: worldwide tax from day one. Jay: non-permanent resident years first
9How many US credits and Japanese pension years will each of you have, given your move year?ClockUS credits building. Dako has zero Japanese years
10What is your FIRE number in yen?DialNot calculated
11Which country’s school is the main one?One-way door, slowlyBlank
12How much of the second language do the kids hear in a week?ClockWords, not sentences
13What visa or status does the non-Japanese spouse need, and how long does it take?One-way door (order matters)Researched only
14If two bases, how many months a year in each?DialNot set
15Who carries the admin load in each country?DialIn Japan, Dako
16Which country does each of you picture at 75?None of the aboveUnanswered

Where our own worksheet stands

Look down the last column and a pattern shows up. Every clock row has an answer. The blanks sit in the doors and the dials: the green card, the yen number, the main school, the months.

That’s the most useful thing three months bought us. Undecided and unprepared turn out to be different states. The doors can wait, as long as we know what closes them. Row 4 shows it: gifts are treated differently before and after an exit, so it has to be settled before row 2 is.

Our first post asked what keeping the door open one more year costs. We can at least say where that cost lives now. Mostly it’s row 2. Every year the card stays in Dako’s wallet is another year of worldwide tax and reporting, paid for the privilege of not deciding. Row 11 will get a deadline of its own. Most of the rest can sit a little longer.

If you copy the table, start with your clock rows. They won’t wait.

FAQ

Is splitting time between the US and Japan a way to avoid Japanese tax residency?

Not reliably. Japan looks at where your life is centered, not a day count, and there’s no 183-day rule in its residency test. A family with a home and daily life in Japan can be treated as resident even while spending months abroad.

When should a cross-border couple start planning a possible move?

Before the clocks decide for you. For a green card holder, that means knowing your calendar-year count now. Gifts between spouses are treated differently before and after an exit, so put them in order first. Kids’ school entry sets its own timeline.

Is there a downloadable version of the worksheet?

The table above is the whole thing. Copy it, add a column for each option you’re weighing, and fill in the clock rows first.


This article describes our own planning process and general rules in US and Japanese tax, immigration, and pension systems. It isn’t tax, legal, or investment advice. Rules and thresholds change, and your answers depend on your own facts. Please talk to qualified professionals in both countries, and see our Disclaimer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *