By Jay
I have never had to choose a country. I’m American, and nobody has ever handed me a form asking me to confirm it. My kids are different. They were born here with two nationalities, and Japanese law says that somewhere around their twentieth birthday, they’re supposed to pick one.
Sort of. That “sort of” is most of this post.
I’m the parent who can’t read the Japanese paperwork. Dako filed the birth registration paperwork at the consulate, the way she handles every piece of Japanese bureaucracy in our house. Until now my understanding of the nationality question was “the kids have both, and at some point there’s a thing.” This is me finally reading the law, in translation, and writing down what the thing actually is. If you’re the non-Japanese parent in a family like ours, I wrote this for you.
The deadline my kids have, and I don’t
Start with how they got two nationalities in the first place, because the first deadline already happened and you may not know you passed it.
Japan’s Nationality Act says a child is Japanese if either parent was Japanese at the time of birth. But a child born outside Japan who also gets a foreign nationality at birth, which is most children born in the US, loses the Japanese one retroactively unless the parents reserve it. The reservation is a notice filed together with the birth registration at a Japanese consulate. The Family Register Act gives you three months from the birth to file it. Miss the window and the consulate won’t accept the registration. The child is treated as never having been Japanese.
We made that window. I’d love to say I understood what we were doing. Dako filed it, and I knew we’d done something important and not much more than that.
There is a repair route for families who miss it, but it’s narrow. A child under eighteen can re-acquire Japanese nationality by notifying the Ministry of Justice, provided the child actually lives in Japan at the time. Visiting grandparents doesn’t count. The ministry defines “living in Japan” as having your base of life there. So for a US-based family, missing the three months usually means the door stays shut until a move.
Then comes the deadline this post is named for. Under Article 14, a person who became a dual national before turning eighteen has to choose one nationality by age twenty. Someone who became dual after eighteen gets two years from that point. Before April 2022, when Japan lowered the age of adulthood, the numbers were twenty and twenty-two. Some English-language pages, including some of the Ministry of Justice’s own, still show the old ones.
So that’s the asymmetry in one sentence. I’m a US citizen for life with no paperwork. My kids have a date.
What Japan’s nationality “choice” actually requires (and what it doesn’t)
Here’s where I expected a renunciation ceremony and found something much softer.
There are two ways to choose Japan. The first is to actually give up the other nationality under that country’s rules. The second is to file a “declaration of choice” with a Japanese municipal office or consulate. Filing is free. It needs no attachments beyond, in some cases, a copy of the family register. A child fifteen or older signs it themselves. That declaration, by itself, satisfies the Article 14 obligation.
What it does not do is remove the other nationality. The Ministry of Justice says so directly: whether the foreign nationality is actually lost depends on the foreign country’s law. Japan can’t make the US un-citizen anyone. What Japan asks instead, under Article 16, is that a person who declared for Japan “endeavor” to renounce the foreign nationality. The law attaches no penalty to not endeavoring, and no case of anyone losing Japanese nationality for failing to has been reported, as far as I could find.
There is a stick in the law, in theory. Article 15 lets the Minister of Justice send a written demand to someone who missed the deadline, and if they don’t choose within a month of receiving it, they lose Japanese nationality automatically. In practice, that demand appears never to have been sent. A ministry official told the Diet in 2009 that there had been no instances, and the reporting I found since, through 2025, says the same. A Japanese bar association estimate quoted by one advocacy group puts the share of people who should have filed the declaration and haven’t at around eighty percent. That’s a single secondhand figure, so hold it loosely. The direction is clear enough. Missing the deadline doesn’t cancel the duty. The ministry says you still have to file. But as far as anyone has reported, it hasn’t cost anyone their nationality.
In 2018, reporting cited a Ministry of Justice estimate that roughly 890,000 people had been in a position to hold dual nationality by birth since 1985. Nobody publishes how many of them file the declaration each year.
So when I say my kids will have to choose a country “sort of,” this is what I mean. They’ll have to file a form that says Japan. They won’t have to stop being American to file it.
What the US side says: nothing, which is its own kind of answer
I went looking for the American version of Article 14 and there isn’t one. The State Department’s page on dual nationality says US law “does not mention dual nationality or require a person to choose one nationality or another.” Dual nationals owe allegiance to both countries, have to enter and leave the US on a US passport, and that’s roughly the whole policy.
Losing US citizenship is hard to do by accident. The statute requires a voluntary act performed with the intention of giving up US nationality, and for naturalizing abroad or swearing a foreign oath, the act only counts if you were already eighteen. State Department regulations go further: for routine acts like a foreign naturalization or oath, the government presumes you intended to keep your US citizenship unless you tell a consular officer otherwise. And the burden of proof is on whoever claims you lost it.
I’m not a lawyer, and I didn’t find a State Department document that mentions Japan’s declaration of choice by name. But reading the two systems side by side, a Japanese declaration filed by a nineteen-year-old doesn’t look like anything US law would treat as giving up citizenship. It isn’t a renunciation, and renunciation has its own procedure. You appear in person before a US consular officer abroad and swear an oath, and the result is irrevocable. A parent can’t do it for a child. The fee for that oath was $2,350 for about a decade. It dropped to $450 on April 13, 2026.
Put the two countries together and the picture is lopsided. Japan has the rule and, as far as has been reported, has never enforced it. The US, the country with no rule, has made it nearly impossible to lose the status without meaning to. My kids’ American citizenship is the sturdier of the two, and it’s the one that asks almost nothing of them.
How the choice interacts with where we end up living
We still don’t know whether we’ll move to Japan, split our time, or stay. The nationality rules care about that question, and not only for the kids.
Dako is a Japanese citizen with a green card, and she’s written that she leans toward naturalizing in the US, without having decided. Article 11 of the same law is blunt about what that would mean: a Japanese national who acquires a foreign nationality by their own choice loses Japanese nationality. Automatically, no form required, though she’d be expected to report it within three months. Japan’s courts have been asked to strike that provision down. The Tokyo High Court upheld it in February 2023, and the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal that September. Other challenges have failed since.
Follow that through and the house gets strange. If Dako naturalizes, both parents hold one nationality, and it’s mine. The kids would be the only Japanese nationals under our roof, holding a nationality neither parent has, with a deadline attached that neither parent ever faced.
Where we live changes how much the Japanese declaration matters, too. From the US, it’s a form in a drawer. From Japan, it’s a form the ministry expects. But the difference between “has Japanese nationality” and “doesn’t” is the large one, and it was the three-month window at birth that decided it, not anything at twenty.
What we plan to tell our kids, and when
We haven’t told them anything. They’re small, and we haven’t even had the money conversation yet, let alone the citizenship one.
Dako and I have talked about it, though, and where we’ve landed is loose on purpose. Our current thinking is that when the deadline comes, the kids should decide for themselves, based on where they are and what their lives look like at that point. We have time, so we haven’t pushed the idea further than that. It’s a direction, not a plan.
What I keep turning over is the asymmetry. I’ve never had to think about which country I belong to, because the answer was given. My kids are going to get asked, and asked by a government that, as far as anyone can tell, won’t do anything if they don’t answer. That’s a strange gift. They get the question and the freedom to answer it slowly. I’d rather they knew the rules before they got the form, so that when it arrives, it’s a thing they understand and not a thing their mother has to translate for them.
That, as much as anything, is why I finally read the law.
FAQ
Do my kids lose their US citizenship if they declare for Japan?
Not under any reading of US law we could find. Loss of US nationality requires a voluntary act done with the intent to give it up, and the government presumes you meant to keep it. Japan’s declaration isn’t a renunciation of anything on the US side.
What happens if they never file the Japanese declaration?
Legally, the duty remains and the Ministry of Justice says they should still file. In practice, the ministry’s power to demand a choice appears never to have been used. As far as has been publicly reported, no one has lost Japanese nationality through it.
We missed the three-month window at birth. Is it over?
Not necessarily, but the repair is narrow. A child under eighteen can re-acquire Japanese nationality by notification if the child’s base of life is in Japan at the time. From the US, that usually means waiting for a move.
Will the Japanese parent lose Japanese nationality by naturalizing in the US?
Yes, under Article 11, automatically. Japanese courts upheld that rule in 2023.
Nationality law changes, and consulate requirements differ in their details. Confirm deadlines and documents with your nearest Japanese consulate and, for US questions, with a qualified attorney. Nothing here is legal advice; see our disclaimer.