Why a US Financial Advisor’s Advice Expires at the Border: Five Textbook Moves That Flip in Japan

This post may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Nothing here is personalized advice: see our Disclaimer.

By Dako

We’ve paid for financial advice twice. Once around 2023, and once more starting in early 2025. Each time we gave it about a year. Each time we stopped, for the same reason: we were paying a percentage of our assets every year and couldn’t point to a single decision that was better because of it.

I don’t think either advisor was bad at their job. I think their job was a different job. They were trained to optimize a household that will live, retire, and die inside the United States. We’re not that household. We might retire in Japan, or split our time between the two countries. Most of the advisors and accountants we’ve met didn’t understand that two-country setup. The part that stung is that they didn’t try to.

This post is about why that happens. It isn’t about bad advisors. It’s about good US advice that stops being good at a specific line on a map, and the awkward position a family lands in when nobody in the room is paid to know that.

“There’s a treaty, so a good US advisor is enough”

It’s a reasonable assumption. The US and Japan have an income tax treaty, so surely the two systems have been reconciled by someone smarter than any of us, and surely a competent US planner can work inside that.

Two things in the treaty itself say otherwise.

The first is the saving clause. Article 1 says the treaty doesn’t stop the United States from taxing its own citizens as if the treaty didn’t exist, with a short list of exceptions. For an American spouse like Jay, that means moving to Japan doesn’t switch off US taxation. It adds Japanese taxation on top. We’ve written about how the treaty actually works and won’t repeat it here.

The second is Article 17. Pensions and similar payments are taxable only in the country where you live. Read that from the US side and it sounds like relief. Read it from Japan’s side and it means Japan gets the first claim on your retirement income once you’re a resident there. Japan then applies its own rules to what comes out, and Japan’s rules were not written with US accounts in mind.

One more layer, because it changes who the advice is for. Japan sorts residents into categories. A foreign national spends roughly the first five years as a “non-permanent resident,” taxed on foreign income only to the extent it’s paid into or sent to Japan. A Japanese national gets no such grace period. I would be taxed on worldwide income from the day I land. So the same household holds two different tax clocks, and advice that works for Jay’s accounts in year two can be wrong for mine in year one. We’ve been through this with the 401(k)s already.

A US advisor isn’t trained on any of that. Not because they’re careless. Because most of it is Japanese law.

Five pieces of textbook US advice that flip once Japan is your tax home

Here are the moves a good US planner will recommend, and what I’ve found happens to each one on the Japanese side. Where the sourcing is thin, I’ll say so, because thin is the honest state of this field.

1. Convert to a Roth. The US logic is airtight: pay tax now, never pay tax on the growth. Japan doesn’t import the label. There is no NTA guidance addressing Roth IRAs by name. The practitioners who work on this treat the earnings portion of a Roth withdrawal as taxable Japanese income, usually miscellaneous income for periodic withdrawals or one-time income for a lump sum. The cruel part is the credit. Because the US charges nothing on a qualified Roth distribution, there’s no US tax to credit against the Japanese bill. You prepaid in one country for a discount that the other country doesn’t honor. One Japanese tax accountant’s site goes as far as suggesting people close a Roth before returning to Japan. I’m not endorsing that. I’m pointing out that “always convert” and “consider closing” are being said about the same account, depending on which side of the border you’re standing on.

2. Buy municipal bonds for tax-free income. US munis pay interest that’s exempt from federal tax. Japan has no category for US state and local bonds. Interest on foreign bonds is simply interest income, taxed at a flat 20.315% for a resident. I couldn’t find a single NTA page that mentions US municipal bonds by name, so treat this as the textbook application of a general rule rather than a ruling. The direction is still clear. An investment whose entire reason to exist is a US tax exemption loses that reason the day Japan becomes your tax home, while keeping whatever yield you accepted in exchange for it.

3. Fund the 529. We do this, and I’ve written about why we still chose it. But the US advice comes with a US promise, tax-free growth for education, and Japan makes no such promise. The one Japan-side tax firm I found that addresses 529s says Japan doesn’t simply import the US result and would look at the earnings component on its own terms. One firm is not a consensus. It’s also the only one I found, and a US planner is unlikely to know even that much.

4. Max the HSA. This is the account that travels worst. New contributions require a US high-deductible health plan. The move usually ends that. Fidelity’s own policy for customers outside the US says they can’t contribute to an existing HSA at all. And the US tax breaks on the account are US constructs. The same Japan-side source that covers 529s says HSA distributions have to be analyzed item by item for Japanese purposes. Again, thin sourcing. Again, it isn’t something a US planner is likely to raise.

5. Harvest your losses. In the US, a realized loss offsets gains, then up to $3,000 of ordinary income, and the rest carries forward. Japan has its own loss rules, and they’re decent: losses offset gains, with a three-year carryforward. But the National Tax Agency ties them to one condition. The sale has to go through a Japanese registered financial institution. A loss taken in a US brokerage account doesn’t qualify, according to a Japanese tax accountant who has answered this question publicly. So once you’re a Japanese resident, harvesting a loss in your US account may do nothing for your Japanese return, while the gains in that same account are generally taxable there. Japan is looking at who executed the trade, not at what you sold.

Notice the pattern. None of these are errors on the US side. They’re all correct, right up to the border. The problem is that each one buys a US tax benefit with something real: a yield you accepted, a tax bill today, a locked-up account. Japan collects the cost without delivering the benefit.

Why cross-border advisors are rare

If the problem is this clear, why isn’t there a thriving industry of people solving it? I went looking, and I found four structural reasons rather than a shortage of smart people.

The first is custody. Fidelity, for one, stopped letting customers living abroad buy mutual funds in 2014, and it doesn’t open accounts for new customers residing outside the US. Its own FAQ also says it doesn’t provide discretionary management to customers residing outside the United States. An advisor can’t manage what the custodian won’t hold.

The second is licensing. Japan’s Financial Services Agency is blunt about it: giving investment advice to Japanese residents as a business requires registration under Japan’s Financial Instruments and Exchange Act, and being located overseas doesn’t exempt you. A US advisor who keeps advising you after you move to Japan may be operating without the registration Japan requires.

The third is credentials. The CFP mark is territorial. There were 107,529 CFP professionals in the US at the end of 2025 and 27,786 in Japan, and the certifying bodies are different organizations. A planner who moves between the two has to re-qualify under the new territory’s rules. I couldn’t find any count of people who hold both. I’d guess it’s small, but it’s a guess.

The fourth is the standard itself. The SEC’s fiduciary duty for investment advisers and its best-interest rule for brokers both govern loyalty and conflicts. Neither says a word about competence in a second country’s tax law. Your advisor can be fully loyal to you and fully ignorant of Japan at the same time, and be in perfect compliance.

The questions we’d ask before trusting any advisor

The CFP Board publishes ten questions to ask a planner, and the SEC’s Form CRS comes with its own list of conversation starters. Both are good. Both assume one country. These are the ones we’d add:

  • Are you registered, or working with someone who is, to advise us once one of us is a tax resident of Japan?
  • Will the custodian keep our accounts open at a Japanese address, and with what restrictions?
  • Which of our accounts lose their US tax status under Japanese law, and in which year, given that one of us is a Japanese national?
  • Do you work alongside a Japanese tax accountant, and who coordinates between you?
  • If we never move, what in your plan changes? If we move in three years, what changes?

The last one is the tell. An advisor who treats “we might move to Japan” as a footnote will answer the same way to both halves. One who understands the problem will give two different answers, and will probably tell you which half they’re less sure about.

Where we stand on getting help

Nowhere good, which is why I’m writing this instead of recommending someone.

We’ve looked for cross-border planners. They exist. The ones we found either set a minimum asset level we don’t meet or charge fees that only make sense at that level. We’ve found expat tax preparers who will file your returns correctly, and that matters, but filing isn’t planning. They’ll report what you did. They won’t tell you what to do. We haven’t tried a Japan-side tax accountant yet, and that’s a gap.

What I actually want is narrow and apparently rare. Someone who knows international tax. Someone who isn’t only interested in households far richer than ours, and isn’t only serving corporate clients. And someone I’d actually want to keep talking to. Any one of those qualities, I could probably find on its own. All four in one person, I haven’t.

So for now, the advisor is me. I read the primary sources, I write posts like this one to make myself check them, and Jay weighs in on the decisions. It’s not the arrangement I’d design. It’s the one that’s available. My suspicion, and it’s only a suspicion, is that most families in our position end up here too. The help exists. It was priced and built for someone else.

If you’re in that spot, I’d rather you hear it plainly than keep assuming you’ve missed some obvious door. We haven’t found one either.

FAQ

Can’t I just keep my US advisor after moving to Japan?

Maybe, but check two things. Whether your custodian will keep your accounts active at a Japanese address, and whether your advisor is permitted to advise a Japanese resident under Japan’s licensing rules. Ask both before you move, not after.

Does the tax treaty protect my Roth IRA in Japan?

Not in any way we could find. The treaty gives Japan the taxing right over pension-type income for Japanese residents, and Japan has issued no guidance recognizing Roth accounts as tax-free. Practitioners treat the growth as taxable Japanese income.

Is a Japanese CFP a cross-border advisor?

Not automatically. A Japanese CFP is certified under Japan’s program, just as a US CFP is certified under the US one. Cross-border competence is a separate thing you have to ask about directly.

Should I fire my advisor if I might move to Japan?

I wouldn’t put it that way. Ask them the five questions above. If the answers don’t change between “we stay” and “we move,” you’ve learned what you needed to.

Tax treatment of US accounts for Japanese residents is an area with little official guidance. Several points above rest on practitioner interpretation rather than rulings. Verify anything you act on with a qualified professional in both countries. Nothing here is tax or investment advice; see our disclaimer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *